# Celtic Hoard Nobody Reclaimed: New Study of 20 Buried Ingots Gets Closer to Solving a Nearly 200-Year-Old Mystery

*New study using osmium isotopes and trace elements investigates the provenance of 20 Early Iron Age ingots from the Speyer depot*

By Sandee Oster · Published 19 November 2026

Source: https://archaeologyteahouse.com/stories/celtic-hoard-nobody-reclaimed

Primary source: [Provenance investigation using Re–Os isotopes and trace element analyses of Hallstatt C–D and La Tène A bipyramidal ingots from the Speyer depot (upper Rhine region, Germany)](https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jas.2026.106714)

Subjects: [Speyer](https://www.wikidata.org/entity/Q6829), [Ingot](https://www.wikidata.org/entity/Q83893), [Celtic culture](https://www.wikidata.org/entity/Q9706709)

---

![](https://archaeologyteahouse.com/media/01a1bc3e-6e09-704e-b8fb-b0127a59cd12/960.webp)

*The Speyer depot consisting of 20 double-pointed ingots. Top view. Photo: GDKE, LA-Speyer, A. Laube*

I recently visited Speyer. I visited its cathedral and museum, walked its old cobbled streets, and saw the ruins of one of the oldest synagogues north of the Alps. My historical journey began and ended mostly in its medieval era. But Speyer has been home to people for far, far longer.

In fact, sometime during the Early Iron Age, someone or multiple people dug a pit in a forest between Speyer and Schifferstadt and placed twenty iron bars (ingots) within. Each was about half a meter long and weighed almost 5 kg. They look a bit like the arrows on a compass or the pointers of a clock. Then they walked away and never returned.

Similar ingots have been found across Central Europe, more than 4 tonnes in fact. Yet despite nearly 200 years of research, one basic question remains unanswered: where did all that iron come from?

In 2020, researchers unearthed those Speyer ingots once more. To figure out exactly where they came from, archaeologist Ivan Stepanov and his colleagues subjected the ingots to a barrage of scientific analyses, including one never used on archaeological iron before. The results brought them much closer to answering where the ingots came from, but they also raised a new mystery.

### Iron Ingots and Celtic Princes

![](https://archaeologyteahouse.com/media/01a1bc3f-2599-7718-945b-f41426811aa1/1600.webp)

*The locations of bi-pointed ingots and the Speyer depot (red arrow). Credit: Stepanov et al. 2026*

Also called bipyramidal ingots, they are some of the earliest evidence of mass production and iron exchange during the Hallstatt C–D and La Tène A periods (ca. 8th–5th centuries BCE).

This type of ingot emerged during a period of major social change, when ‘princely residences’ and ‘princely graves’ began appearing across the landscape. These were marked by fortified hilltop settlements, Mediterranean imports, and genetic and cultural exchange across the Alpine region. They controlled raw materials, particularly salt and iron, and facilitated long-distance exchange of luxury goods.

Each iron ingot would have had around 4–8 kg of metal, enough to make prestigious objects like swords or chariot parts, themselves symbols of wealth and power among the Celtic warrior elite. With some ingots found within major power centres, including Heuneburg, Mont Lassois, and Messein, it is suggested that they may have provided a source of wealth, power, and status.

Most ingots are stray finds, often without much context. Many are found lying along major rivers or within wetlands. The Speyer ingots were found about 3 km west of the Rhine River, on one of the main transport corridors linking northern and southern Central Europe, and within the sphere of influence of one of the early Iron Age’s major power centres, Bad Dürkheim.

They were found in a pit, alone, with no other finds. What makes them even more special is that they are of a type called BLS4, the least common of all types. At present, fewer than 50 are known across Central Europe, largely within the Rhine and Moselle river valleys.

Each is incredibly similar, weighing around 4.9 kg and measuring roughly 50 cm long. Such uniformity would have required great skill and precision in the smithy. One of the biggest differences is that some have square ends, while others have a rectangular cross-section or both. This may indicate different smiths, or the work of an apprentice still figuring out how to get the shape just right.

### The Mystery of Their Origin

![](https://archaeologyteahouse.com/media/01a1bc56-0adc-7c88-8bc2-2250fbdd2bae/960.webp)

*Findspot of the Speyer ingot depot. Photo: GDKE, LA-Speyer, A. Laube*

Previous attempts to figure out where these ingots came from relied on Os isotope analysis combined with slag-inclusion analysis. It confirmed that the iron ingots were often made by combining two blooms (an iron lump mixed with slag) of different origin. It also showed that ingots found in very different areas often had similar geochemical signatures. What it couldn’t do was pin down where the iron actually came from.

One problem is that few Hallstatt C–D (ca. 800–450 BCE) smelting sites are known. What likely happened is that very few iron producers existed at the time, and furnaces were built away from settlements, making them and their iron sources harder to find.

Stepanov and his colleagues analyse the Speyer depot and 40 ore samples from across southern Germany. They used a rhenium-osmium (Re-Os) isotope method, something never before done on archaeological iron.

Osmium is different. It occurs in very small amounts in natural iron deposits, and its natural signature varies by ore deposit because it forms from the radioactive decay of rhenium into osmium. That means ore deposits can have a very different osmium fingerprint.

What’s more, osmium is ‘iron-loving’. During smelting, its fingerprint passes from the ore to the finished product unchanged. Other elements are ‘rock-loving’, meaning they end up mostly in the slag.

So, to trace the Speyer depot, the team measured the ratio of rhenium to osmium, as well as analysing the small slag inclusions found in the iron. They then compared these results with 40 ore samples from southern Germany, and a database of other sites across France and Germany.

The team also wanted to know how old the iron was. To do this, they radiocarbon-dated it.

Hold on a minute, radiocarbon dating can only be used on organic materials. Things like charcoal, wood, leather, and bone.

Most iron made in ancient Europe and Africa was so-called wrought iron. It’s mainly iron, but it also has small amounts of carbon. Basically, when the iron was heated in a furnace, some carbon from the charcoal got trapped. Since charcoal is wood, and therefore organic, it contains carbon-14 and can thus be dated.

### The Mysterious Origin of the Ingots

![](https://archaeologyteahouse.com/media/01a1bc41-2baa-7e41-8e56-a65d30868298/1600.webp)

*Graph comparing the osmium content and osmium isotope ratios of the Speyer ingots and iron ores. Credit: Stepanov et al. 2026*

Two radiocarbon dates fell within the Hallstatt period (800-400 BCE), supporting the idea that the rare BLS-type ingots are broadly contemporary with most other bi-pointed ingots.

And where did they come from?

It turned out that ruling out places was easier than pinpointing a single origin.

The iron most likely did not match ores from the Vosges, the northern Black Forest, the Danube Valley, the western Black Forest’s bog ores, or probably the Swabian Alb’s pea ores. The Dogger, Minette, and even the local Palatinate ores were also probably no match.

This suggests the ore for most of the ingots likely came from the area north of the Alps. The absolute closest matches in the rare-earth element patterns came from the Haye Plateau in Lorraine.

But there is a problem: the Haye ore is rich in lead, cadmium, arsenic, and zinc. The Speyer iron does not have these. Similarly, their osmium fingerprints differ. This means the iron likely came from another geochemically similar, unknown ore deposit somewhere in Lorraine, or perhaps southern Luxembourg, though the Haye Plateau cannot yet be fully ruled out.

Then there’s ingot number 16. Like the black sheep in a flock, it stands out for trace elements and osmium values that differ from the other iron bars in the Speyer deposit.

This suggests the Speyer deposit came from two different, still-unknown ore sources. Most came from one, likely in Lorraine or Luxembourg, and one (No. 16) from another, possibly influenced by volcanic rocks. Each ore was then likely smelted into blooms. Before, finally, all probably reached the same specialised workshop, hence their near-identical size and weight, where they were forged into ingots.

The findings, although they cannot pinpoint an exact ore source, are still important. They imply far-reaching long-distance trade networks that may have been linked to, and possibly even controlled by, the princely residences that began popping up at the time.

Because iron was a valuable commodity at the time, mining, producing, and trading this prestigious material may have helped Celtic elites maintain wealth, status, and power.

The analysis also suggests that making these ingots was not a simple process, with all stages occurring in the same areas and workshops. Smelting and working the iron likely took place across equally long distances. These distances are exemplified by workshops found in earlier studies in Weyersheim and Sévaz, roughly 70 km apart. This suggests workshops likely relied on trade networks to get iron from far-flung smelting sites.

But these ingots were so incredibly valuable. Why bury them in a nondescript pit never to return?

Burying valuable objects, including iron ingots, was common at the time. The reasons are uncertain. The researchers suggest that because so many occur along major trade routes like rivers, traders may have buried them as an offering to the gods for safe passage and protection. Alternatively, they may have left them there for safekeeping to prevent thieves from taking them.

---

Researchers have identified over 4 tonnes of iron ingots so far. Analysis suggests most came from a relatively limited area. Exactly where that is still a mystery, but the new study has narrowed down some possible locations.

Next, the researchers plan to analyse more ingots, as well as more ore deposits and smithing waste, hopefully solving the enduring nearly two-century-long mystery of their provenance.

Knowing where these early Celtic societies sourced their iron can help us better reconstruct their trade networks and see how communities connected, organised around trade, and developed and maintained themselves.

*Let me know what you think, and if you'd like to support this blog and the person writing it, you can *[*chip in once, monthly, or yearly.*](https://archaeologyteahouse.com/support)* Only if you'd like to.*

### References

Stepanov, I., Brauns, M., Gassmann, G., Bentz, M., Hünerfauth, B., Marquart, M., ... & Pernicka, E. (2026). Provenance investigation using Re–Os isotopes and trace element analyses of Hallstatt C–D and La Tène A bipyramidal ingots from the Speyer depot (upper Rhine region, Germany). *Journal of Archaeological Science*, *196*, 106714. [https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jas.2026.106714](https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jas.2026.106714)

## Common questions

**Who found the ingots, and how were they lying?**

The depot is labelled “Speyer 286” and was discovered in 2020 by Natalia Helm

**Which ingots were dated, and how?**

Ingots No. 8 and No. 11, both with carbon-rich areas in the metal. Small shavings were drilled out and burned, and the resulting carbon dioxide was turned into graphite for radiocarbon measurement.
